
Why Attorneys General Matter
In this next edition of the NCRA Election Desk, we look at the elections next month for attorneys general. For NCRA and our members, AGs matter far more than governors because AGs tend to have more input on and influence over legislation, like privacy, data security, data brokers, and more. Oftentimes, the party of the AG does not matter, as even conservative Republicans can support, for example, more regulation of data companies and other “pro-consumer” issues.
Becoming a state A.G. differs from most other statewide offices. In 43 states and the District of Columbia, voters elect attorneys general directly. But in seven other states, it’s more complicated. In five states (Alaska, Hawaii, New Hampshire, New Jersey, and Wyoming), governors appoint attorneys general. In Maine, the full state legislature chooses the attorney general via a joint session/secret ballot for a two-year term. In Tennessee, the state Supreme Court appoints the attorney general, who serves an eight-year term
Pre-2026 attorneys general party composition (50*)
- 27 Republican AGs
- 24 Democratic AGs
* Including the District of Columbia
A Historical View
From 1971 to 2011, Democrats had a commanding control of state AG seats. Democrats peaked at 34 seats in 1993. Republicans reached their peak of 28 in 2026. Democratic control lasted from the midterm after President Nixon’s first election to President Obama’s first election. The Republican margin has steadily increased in the last few years. While some states are flippier than others, the most solidly AG partisan states are Nebraska, which has had 75 years of continuous Republican control, Maryland with 72 years of Democratic control, Connecticut with 67 years of Democratic control, and South Dakota, with 51 years of Republican control.
The 2026 Election: Pre-Election
In 2026, 30 AG seats were up for election. The 11 open seats mean that more than 20% of AG’s will be new next year, along with staff. That is a lot of change that brings opportunities and risks. The transition to a new attorney general and his/her team can bring different enforcement priorities and legislative and regulatory approaches, all of which could impact compliance requirements and legal strategies. Businesses may need to adjust quickly to these changes or face increased scrutiny under a new A.G. administration. Additionally, uncertainty around these transitions can affect strategic planning, particularly for heavily regulated industries, such as financial services, privacy, data security, and technology.
Direct election
- 30 Races
- Republican = 14
- Democratic = 16
- 19 Incumbents running for reelection
- Republican = 7 (AR, FL, ID, IA, KS, NE, ND)
- Democratic = 12 (AZ, CA, CT, DE, IL, MD, MA, MN, NM, NY, VT, WI)
- 11 Open seats
- Republican = 7 (AL, GA, OH, OK, SC, SD, TX)
- Democratic = 4 (CO, MI, NV, RI)
Indirect election
- 6 Seats filled by the governor or legislature
- AG Races = 4
- Republican = 3
- Alaska (appointed by governor). The Democratic candidate for governor, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, is ahead in the election returns. This was an interesting race between one Democrat, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, and three Republicans, Bernadette Wilson, Dave Bronson, and Treg Taylor. Since 2022, Alaska has used the current system, in which candidates of all parties compete in a single primary, and the top four candidates advance to the general election. The November election is then decided by ranked-choice voting. Under that practice, voters rank their preferences; if there is no majority winner after a first round of tabulation, lower choices factor in.
- New Hampshire (appointed by governor). Governor Kelly Ayotte, a Republican, was reelected.
- Wyoming (appointed by governor). Eric Barlow, the Republican, was elected as governor.
- Democratic = 1
- Maine (appointed by legislature). Attorney General Aaron Frey (D) cannot stand for reelection. The Maine legislature will state in Republican hands.
- Republican = 3
- Hawaii will elect a governor in 2028, and New Jersey in 2029.
- AG Races = 4
The 2026 Election: Post-Election
Direct elections
- Democrats won 20 of the 31 AG races.
- There will be 13 new AGs. That’s 26% of all state AGs.
- New Democratic AGs: Jena Griswold (Colorado), Tanya Miller (Georgia), Nate Willems (Iowa), Chris Mann (Kansas), John Kulewicz (Ohio), Eli Savit (Michigan), Nathan Johnson (Texas), Nicole Cannizzaro (Nevada), and Kimberly Ahern (Rhode Island).
New Republican AGs: Katherine Robertson (Alabama), Jon Echols (Oklahoma), David Stumbo (South Carolina), Lance Russell (South Dakota).
- New Democratic AGs: Jena Griswold (Colorado), Tanya Miller (Georgia), Nate Willems (Iowa), Chris Mann (Kansas), John Kulewicz (Ohio), Eli Savit (Michigan), Nathan Johnson (Texas), Nicole Cannizzaro (Nevada), and Kimberly Ahern (Rhode Island).
- Five states (Georgia, Iowa, Kansas, Ohio, and Texas) have flipped from Republican to Democratic control.
- The last Democratic AGs before this from the five flipped seats (Georgia, 2011; Iowa, 2023; Kansas, 2011; Ohio, 2011 (Richard Cordray); and Texas, 1999).
Indirect elections
- Alaska (appointed by governor). RESULT PENDING. The Democratic candidate for governor, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, is ahead in the election returns. This was an interesting race between one Democrat, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, and three Republicans, Bernadette Wilson, Dave Bronson, and Treg Taylor. Since 2022, Alaska has used the current system, in which candidates of all parties compete in a single primary, and the top four candidates advance to the general election. The November election is then decided by ranked-choice voting. Under that practice, voters rank their preferences; if there is no majority winner after a first round of tabulation, lower choices factor in.
- Maine (appointed by the legislature). REMAINS DEMOCRATIC. Attorney General Aaron Frey (D) cannot stand for reelection. The Maine legislature will state in Republican hands.
- New Hampshire (appointed by the governor). REMAINS REPUBLICAN. Governor Kelly Ayotte, a Republican, was reelected.
- Wyoming (appointed by governor). REMAINS REPUBLICAN. Eric Barlow, the Republican, was elected as governor.
- The new split:
- 29 Democrats
- 21 Republicans
- 1 Pending
Looking Ahead to 2027
- Republican = 3
- Kentucky
- Mississippi (incumbent eligible to run again)
- Louisiana (incumbent eligible to run again)
- Democratic = 0
Looking ahead to 2028, direct elections = 10
- Republican = 6
- IN, MO, MT, PA, UT, WV
- Democratic = 4
- NC, OR, VT, WA
Looking ahead to 2028, indirect elections
- TBD = 3
- Hawaii will elect a governor in 2028. The current Democratic governor has appointed the A.G.
- The Maine legislature elects an attorney general every two years. The current Democratic legislature has appointed the A.G.
- New Hampshire elects its governor every two years. The current Republican governor has appointed the A.G.
Looking ahead to 2029
- TBD = 1
- New Jersey will elect a governor in 2029. The current Democratic legislature has appointed the A.G.